No deal yet on EU climate targets as COP30 looms

No deal yet on EU climate targets as COP30 looms
Brazil's Finance Minister Fernando Haddad speaks next to Simon Stiell, Executive Secretary of UN Climate Change (UNFCCC), and Brazil's COP30 President Andre Correa do Lago during the ministerial preparatory meeting (Pre-COP30), ahead of the COP30 Climate Summit, in Brasilia, Brazil. (Reuters)
Short Url
Updated 3 sec ago

No deal yet on EU climate targets as COP30 looms

No deal yet on EU climate targets as COP30 looms
  • EU countries have been haggling for months over two separate targets for slashing greenhouse-gas emissions: one for 2035 that they must bring to the UN climate talks, and the other for 2040

BRUSSELS: The European Union’s member states have not yet reached an agreement on key emissions targets before the UN’s COP30 summit in Brazil, and ministers will meet again on Wednesday to thrash out a deal, according to Brussels officials.
EU countries have been haggling for months over two separate targets for slashing greenhouse-gas emissions: one for 2035 that they must bring to the UN climate talks, and the other for 2040.
Talks in Brussels ended on Tuesday without an accord and continued through the night.
“We believe we have the basis for a political deal. We expect to formally conclude a deal when we resume in a few hours,” a spokesman for Denmark, which currently holds the EU’s rotating presidency, said early on Wednesday.
EU officials have stressed the importance of the talks, which come ahead of the COP30 summit next week in Brazil.
French Environment Minister Monique Barbut had warned that turning up empty-handed to the summit would spell “disaster” for the EU.
Behind only China, the United States and India in terms of emissions, the EU has been the most committed of the major polluters to climate action and has already cut emissions by 37 percent compared to 1990 levels.
But after blazing a trail, the EU’s political landscape has shifted right, and climate concerns have taken a backseat to defense and competitiveness — with concerns in some capitals that greening Europe’s economy is harming growth.
“It’s very, very difficult,” said an EU diplomat, summing up the state of play in Brussels late Tuesday.
Denmark was understood to be working hard to win over Italy, one of the countries most skeptical of the proposed targets.
The most urgent challenge for ministers is to reach a unanimous deal on an EU emissions target for 2035, known as a Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), which Paris Agreement signatories are supposed to bring to the COP30.
“I want our heads of state and government to go to Brazil with a very strong mandate, a clear leadership role for Europe,” German Environment Minister Carsten Schneider said.
The EU also hopes to lock in the support of a weighted majority of countries for the next big climate target set out by the European Commission on the path to carbon neutrality by 2050.
The EU executive said in July it wanted to cut emissions by 90 percent by 2040, compared to 1990 levels — a major stride toward net zero.
But member states have yet to endorse that next step, which would require sweeping changes to industry and daily life at a time of growing concern over adverse impacts on Europe’s economy.
Spain and the Nordic countries support the 2040 proposal, as does Germany, with some caveats. But Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic and Italy remain opposed, citing risks to their industrial sectors.
Heavyweight France, meanwhile, has kept observers guessing on its position — demanding guarantees that its nuclear sector would not lose out under green transition plans and wiggle room on emissions should Europe’s forests absorb less carbon than expected.

- ‘Not pretty’ -

To win over the staunchest skeptics, Tuesday’s talks covered a range of “flexibilities” for member states, including letting countries count carbon credits purchased to finance projects outside Europe.
A commission pledge for credits to account for up to three percent of a nation’s 2040 emission cuts failed to win over hard-liners, with countries pushing for a higher threshold of five percent.
Some also want the overall objective reassessed every two years.
Environmental groups have accused countries of undermining the EU’s climate ambitions with loopholes.
But a diplomat involved in the process defended the compromise shaping up in Brussels, while conceding it was “not necessarily pretty.”
“In the muddy, messy, nasty real world out there, we are trying to achieve something good,” said the diplomat, granted anonymity to discuss the sensitive deliberations.
The EU insists it remains committed to its role as global climate leader, having mobilized 31.7 billion euros ($36.4 billion) in public climate finance in 2024, making it the world’s largest donor.


Tanzanian opposition claims security forces are secretly dumping bodies after election violence

Updated 2 sec ago

Tanzanian opposition claims security forces are secretly dumping bodies after election violence

Tanzanian opposition claims security forces are secretly dumping bodies after election violence
NAIROBI: Authorities in Tanzania faced mounting concern Tuesday over killings during crackdowns on protests surrounding last week’s election, with the largest opposition party alleging that security forces were secretly dumping bodies of hundreds killed in the violence.
Demonstrations spread across the East African country for several days after the Oct. 29 voting as mostly young people took to the streets to protest an election that foreign observers said failed to meet democratic standards because key opposition figures were barred.
Authorities declared a nationwide curfew and security forces cracked down on protests by firing live bullets and tear gas canisters.
The main opposition party, Chadema, has claimed that more than 1,000 people were killed and said Tuesday that security forces were trying to hide the scale of the deaths by secretly disposing of the bodies. The authorities have not responded to the claims.
“Tanzanians’ hearts are bleeding right now. This is a new thing for Tanzanians,” Brenda Rupia, Chadema’s director of communications, said by phone from the commercial capital of Dar es Salaam.
President Samia Suluhu Hassan was declared the winner with more than 97 percent of the vote in a rare landslide victory for the region, but foreign observers said the turnout was low. It was her first election victory — she rose to the presidency automatically as vice president in 2021 after the sudden death of her predecessor, John Pombe Magufuli.
Hassan’s win has been criticized as not credible because her main rivals — Tundu Lissu of Chadema and Luhaga Mpina of ACT-Wazalendo — had been prevented from running. Lissu has been jailed for several months, facing treason allegations stemming from his call for electoral reforms. His deputy, John Heche, was also detained days before voting.
Human Rights Watch on Tuesday condemned the violent crackdown on protesters in a statement that urged Tanzanian authorities to “end the use of excessive and lethal force against protests, and take steps to ensure accountability” by security forces.
The group said various people in Tanzania had cited point-blank shootings by security forces.
The UK, Norway and Canada have cited what they said were credible reports of a large number of fatalities. And the Catholic Church says people died in their “hundreds,” although it was also unable to verify or confirm the exact numbers.
Tanganyika Law Society President Boniface Mwabukusi told The Associated Press that more than 1,000 people died based on accounts his group received and that it was in the process of compiling a report to be shared with international legal organizations.
“The killings were pre-planned to target regions that are known to be politically active, those that are critics of the ruling party. Following people to their homes and killing them amounts to a massacre,” Mwabukusi said.
Rupia, the top Chadema spokesperson, said at least 400 deaths have been reported by its leaders in the Tunduma area of Mbeya region. Other regions also have reported hundreds of victims, she said.
Asked if all the victims were getting funerals, she said that the security forces “are holding dead bodies” and that the remains of victims were being secretly dumped by the security forces to hide the scale of the killings.
Another Chadema official, Deogratius Munishi, said the party would not enter into any political pact with the government until there are electoral and judicial reforms to ensure justice is served. “We want to see those who shot Tanzanians being held accountable,” he said.
Tito Magoti, an independent human rights lawyer based in Dar es Salaam, said Tanzania is “in such crisis” as people look for missing relatives and others come to terms with the number of the dead, which he said is far greater than the figure cited by Chadema.
He said he received a message Tuesday from a citizen near the town of Arusha who reported seeing two army trucks coming from a hospital mortuary loaded with dead bodies. One was full and the other was half-full, he said.
He said he suspected authorities would bury the victims in a forest as part of a cover-up, and added that: “I don’t know know much hospitals are going to be complicit.”
Hassan, Tanzania’s first female leader, was inaugurated on Monday. She acknowledged in her speech that there had been loss of life and urged security agencies to ensure a return to normalcy.
Authorities have warned people not to share photos and videos that may cause panic as the Internet slowly returns after a six-day shutdown. Mobile phone users received a text message on Monday night saying that sharing images that could cause panic or demean human life would lead to “treason charges.”
The messages came shortly after the Internet was reconnected, when people began sharing unverified images of bodies they claimed were victims of the election protests.
A social media page that had been uploading videos and photos of purported election protest victims was pulled down on Monday evening, after attracting thousands of followers within a day.
On Tuesday, life was slowly returning to normal in Dar es Salaam and the administrative capital, Dodoma, with gas stations and grocery shops reopening and public transport resuming after days of closure.
The government spokesperson on Monday asked all public workers to return to work, effectively ending a work-from-home order that had been announced after the curfew imposed on Wednesday.