��������

International dialogues on African development remain fixated on redefining success rather than materially enabling its realization. Groundbreaking research across 40 African nations reveals populations consistently excel in nonmaterial dimensions of human thriving, even amid severe economic constraints. Consider Nigeria, ranked fifth globally in nonfinancial flourishing indicators despite its middle-income status. There, a majority of citizens report robust social relationships and exceptional levels of forgiveness, outperforming wealthier nations. Kenya and Egypt follow closely at seventh and 10th, respectively.

In Senegal and Ghana, over three-quarters of the population experiences daily enjoyment and laughter — testament to emotional resilience untethered from gross domestic product per capita. Rwanda and Ethiopia demonstrate similar strengths, with populations reporting high social well-being metrics such as feeling respected and engaging in daily learning, despite ranking among the world’s least-affluent nations. This divergence is jarring: Sierra Leone, facing heightened food insecurity, ranks 135th in life evaluations globally, yet West African neighbors such as Senegal report surprising levels of optimism about living standards improving.

The contradiction exposes a fatal flaw in current development frameworks. While African societies organically cultivate profound human strengths — communal bonds in Nigeria’s wazobia tradition, Ubuntu-inspired resilience in Southern Africa, or Ethiopia’s dedication to collective learning — the global response offers mere measurement instead of meaningful support. Mauritius’ relatively high global life evaluation ranking coexists with its paradoxical stress levels, proving economic stability alone does not guarantee flourishing.

This evidence demands a rethink: If 87 percent of Nigerians thrive socially without material abundance, why do development policies prioritize economic metrics over social infrastructure? When Kenya outranks industrialized nations in daily enjoyment, yet places 115th in life satisfaction, it reveals the inadequacy of single-dimension assessments. Africa’s organic flourishing, rooted in community, character, and meaning, is not a footnote to development. It is the blueprint. Yet the machinery of international aid remains calibrated to inputs Africa has not requested, ignoring the outputs it demonstrably achieves.

The persistent refinement of well-being metrics, while academically rigorous, risks becoming a sophisticated form of inaction. Consider Tanzania, ranked 11th globally in multidimensional flourishing, yet grappling with systemic gaps in housing and education access. Or Nigeria, where nearly half report financial instability despite the nation’s fifth-place global ranking in nonmaterial flourishing, 87 percent exhibit exceptional character virtues like forgiveness, and three in four maintain robust social bonds. These divergences expose a troubling reality: Cataloging strengths without addressing corresponding deficits is an analytical dead end.

The evidence is unambiguous: Thriving social ecosystems coexist with material deprivation. Kenya, ninth globally in daily learning opportunities, reports only 115th in life satisfaction — a paradox where intellectual curiosity flourishes amid broader systemic challenges. Ethiopia, ranking 121st in educational access, trails Kenya’s emotional resilience. These societies do not require more sophisticated scorecards; they need targeted investment aligned with documented needs.

Yet the development sector remains seduced by quantification. Mauritius’ positive life evaluation masks heightened stress levels, while oil-rich Gabon trails in emotional well-being. At the same time, Algeria’s food insecurity rate of just under 20 percent still represents millions denied basic sustenance. In a nutshell, when indices celebrate non-financial flourishing while material suffering persists, they inadvertently sanitize inequality.

Documenting African resilience, while valuable, remains an insufficient academic exercise if divorced from concrete action.

Hafed Al-Ghwell

Africa’s organic wisdom, collective dignity, intergenerational support, and joy amid adversity, demands more than documentation. It requires deploying resources toward the specific fissures revealed by the data: financial inclusion for Nigeria’s struggling bottom half, educational infrastructure in Tanzania, and healthcare equity from Algeria to Chad. Until then, well-being metrics serve as epitaphs for potential, not blueprints for progress.

Documenting African resilience, while valuable, remains an insufficient academic exercise if divorced from concrete action. True partnership requires channeling resources decisively toward priorities defined by African communities themselves. The evidence is unequivocal: Populations are actively constructing well-being frameworks rooted in indigenous philosophies emphasizing communal bonds over individualistic metrics. Yet the transformative power of these organic structures is systematically throttled by deficits in foundational capabilities.

Consider food insecure countries, where more than two-thirds consistently report lacking money for food. This crippling economic reality directly impedes the potential of community-driven support networks, however strong their cultural foundation. Endless refinement of well-being indicators, while intellectually engaging, becomes a distraction when basic needs remain unmet for vast segments of the population. The imperative is a fundamental redirection: shifting energy and capital toward enabling African-conceived and African-led solutions.

This redirection demands targeted investment in areas proven to underpin dignity and agency, directly addressing the deficiencies quantified in the very surveys critiquing narrow approaches. Chronic underfunding of education, particularly in the humanities essential for ethical reasoning and civic character, must be reversed. The data reveals a continent-wide chasm: Kenya ranks ninth globally for daily learning experiences, reflecting vibrant intellectual engagement, while Algeria languishes at 125th, suggesting systemic barriers to personal development.

Financing educational models that intentionally marry skills training with moral and civic development is not a luxury; it is foundational for sustainable, self-directed flourishing. Similarly, investing in physical infrastructure that enhances daily dignity, for example safe housing, reliable sanitation and accessible clean water is non-negotiable. These are not abstract ideals, but tangible requirements highlighted by low rankings in perceived living standards improvement. Such investments directly tackle the environmental “livability” factors demonstrably linked to well-being.

Crucially, this shift necessitates accepting African definitions of success as legitimate policy blueprints, not anthropological curiosities. Mauritius’ position as Africa’s leader in life evaluations and the consistently high rankings for positive affect across West Africa, measured by, for instance, levels of enjoyment and optimism about the future, are not statistical outliers to be explained away. They are valid, contextually grounded expressions of prosperity emerging from distinct social, cultural, and economic realities.

Policies anchored in externally imposed definitions of progress will inevitably falter. Recognizing the strength inherent in communal orientations, as seen in Nigeria’s high ranking for experiencing harmony with others, or the resilience reflected in Kenya’s unexpectedly high enjoyment ranking despite lower life satisfaction, provides an essential starting point. Prosperity in Africa manifests diversely; policy must reflect this complexity rather than force conformity to foreign — and too often out-of-touch — paradigms. Enabling self-determined priorities means respecting the evidence of what already works within African contexts and scaling it through aligned, substantial resource commitment. The data provides the map; the will to follow it, investing in capabilities and dignity defined from within, is the test of genuine partnership.

When Nigeria consistently outperforms advanced economies on core human dimensions, the message is clear: Africa does not need the world to redefine success; it needs the world to respect and resource its pathways to sustainably achieving it.

• Hafed Al-Ghwell is a senior fellow and executive director of the North Africa Initiative at the Foreign Policy Institute of the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies in Washington, DC. X: @HafedAlGhwell