Several airlines cancel flights to Russia after Azerbaijan Airlines crash
Several airlines cancel flights to Russia after Azerbaijan Airlines crash/node/2584549/world
Several airlines cancel flights to Russia after Azerbaijan Airlines crash
People commemorate victims of an Azerbaijan Airlinesâ passenger plane crash at a memorial installed outside an airport in Baku, Azerbaijan on Dec. 26, 2024. (Reuters)
Short Url
https://arab.news/9zep4
Updated 28 December 2024
AFP
Several airlines cancel flights to Russia after Azerbaijan Airlines crash
Turkmenistan Airlines was the latest airline to announce cancelations Saturday
Kazakhstanâs Qazaq Air has suspended its flights to Yekaterinburg until the end of January
Updated 28 December 2024
AFP
MOSCOW: Several airlines have announced the suspension of flights to Russian cities, after Western experts and the US suggested the crash of the Azerbaijan Airlines this week may have been caused by a Russian anti-aircraft missile.
Moscow has declined to comment on reports the plane could have been accidentally shot down by its air defense.
Russia has said that Grozny, the Chechen capital where the plane was meant to land, was being attacked by Ukrainian drones that day.
It crashed near the Kazakh city of Aktau Wednesday, killing 38 of the 67 people on board.
Turkmenistan Airlines â the national carrier of the reclusive Central Asian state â was the latest airline to announce cancelations Saturday.
It said that âregular flights between Ashgabat-Moscow-Ashgabat were canceled from 30/12/2024 to 31/01/2025,â without giving an explanation.
The decision came after UAE airline flydubai suspended flights between Dubai and the southern Russian cities of Mineralnye Vody and Sochi that were scheduled between December 27 and January 3.
Kazakhstanâs Qazaq Air has suspended its flights to Russiaâs Urals city of Yekaterinburg until the end of January.
Earlier this week, Israeli airline El Al said it was suspending its flights to Moscow for a week.
The Azerbaijan Airlines Embraer 190 crashed near the western Kazakh city of Aktau, on the shores of the Caspian Sea.
It was carrying out a flight between Azerbaijanâs capital Baku and the city of Grozny in Russia.
For several days, some Western experts have been pointing to a crash caused by a Russian anti-aircraft missile.
Citing preliminary results of an investigation, Azerbaijanâs transport minister said Friday that the crash suffered physical âexternal interference.â
Statements from Azerbaijan citing the investigation into the incident suggest Baku believes the plane was hit mid-air.
On Friday, White House spokesman John Kirby said Washington has âindicationsâ Russia may have been responsible, without giving details.
US government shutdown draws closer as congressional leaders head to the White House
Republicans are daring Democrats to vote against legislation that would keep government funding mostly at current levels
Many government offices will be temporarily shuttered and non-exempt federal employees will be furloughed
Updated 7 sec ago
AP
WASHINGTON: Democratic and Republican congressional leaders are heading to the White House for a meeting with President Donald Trump on Monday in a late effort to avoid a government shutdown, but both sides have shown hardly any willingness to budge from their entrenched positions. If government funding legislation is not passed by Congress and signed by Trump on Tuesday night, many government offices across the nation will be temporarily shuttered and non-exempt federal employees will be furloughed, adding to the strain on workers and the nationâs economy. Republicans are daring Democrats to vote against legislation that would keep government funding mostly at current levels, but Democrats so far have held firm. They are using one of their few points of leverage to demand that Congress take up legislation to extend health care benefits. âThe meeting is a first step, but only a first step. We need a serious negotiation,â Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer said in an interview Sunday on NBCâs âMeet the Press.â Trump has shown little interest in entertaining Democratsâ demands on health care, even as he agreed to hold a sit-down meeting Monday afternoon with Schumer, along with Senate Majority Leader John Thune, House Speaker Mike Johnson and House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries. The Republican president has said repeatedly that he fully expects the government to enter a shutdown this week. âIf it has to shut down, itâll have to shut down,â Trump said Friday. âBut theyâre the ones that are shutting down government.â The Trump administration has tried to pressure Democratic lawmakers into backing away from their demands, warning that federal employees could be permanently laid off in the midst of a funding lapse. âChuck Schumer said a few months ago that a government shutdown would be chaotic, harmful and painful. Heâs right, and thatâs why we shouldnât do it,â Thune, a South Dakota Republican, said Sunday on âMeet the Press.â Still, Democrats argued that Trumpâs agreement to hold a meeting shows that he is feeling the pressure to negotiate. They say that because Republicans control the White House and Congress, Americans will mostly blame them for any shutdown. But to hold on to their negotiating leverage, Senate Democrats will likely have to vote against a bill to temporarily extend government funding on Tuesday, just hours before a shutdown â an uncomfortable position for a party that has long denounced shutdowns as pointless and destructive. The bill has already passed the Republican-controlled House and would keep the government funded for seven more weeks while Congress works on annual spending legislation. Any legislation to fund the government will need support from at least 60 senators. That means that at least eight Democrats would have to vote for the short-term funding bill, because Republican Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky is expected to vote against it. During the last potential government shutdown in March, Schumer and nine other Democrats voted to break a filibuster and allow a Republican-led funding bill to advance to a final vote. The New York Democrat faced fierce backlash from many in his own party for that decision, with some even calling for him to step down as Democratic leader. This time, Schumer appears resolute. âWeâre hearing from the American people that they need help on health care and as for these massive layoffs, guess what? Simple one-sentence answer: Theyâre doing it anyway,â he said. Democrats are pushing for an extension to Affordable Care Act tax credits that have subsidized health insurance for millions of people since the COVID-19 pandemic. The credits, which are designed to expand coverage for low- and middle-income people, are set to expire at the end of the year. Some Republicans are open to extending the tax credits, but want changes. Thune said Sunday that the program is âdesperately in need of reformâ and Republicans want to address âwaste, fraud and abuse.â He has pressed Democrats to vote for the funding bill and take up the debate on tax credits at a later date. It remains to be seen whether the White House meeting will help or hurt the chances for a resolution. Negotiations between Trump and Democratic congressional leaders have rarely gone well, and Trump has had little contact with the opposing party during his second term. The most recent negotiation in August between Schumer and the president to speed the pace of Senate confirmation votes for administration officials ended with Trump telling Schumer to âgo to hellâ in a social media post. Trump also abruptly canceled a meeting that was planned with congressional leaders last week, calling Democratsâ demands âunserious and ridiculous.â Schumer argued that the White House coming back to reschedule a meeting for Monday showed that âthey felt the heat.â
Gunman in truck smashes into Michigan church and opens fire, killing at least 4 and injuring 8/node/2617116/world
Gunman in truck smashes into Michigan church and opens fire, killing at least 4 and injuring 8
Police said Thomas Jacob Sanford, 40, drove a pickup truck through the doors of a Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints chapel in Michigan while mass was going on
Sanford then got out of the vehicle, started shooting people and set the church ablaze before leaving. He was killed in a shootout by pursuing police officers
Updated 44 min 53 sec ago
AP
GRAND BLANC TOWNSHIP, Michigan: At least four people were killed and eight injured when a gunman in a pickup truck smashed through the doors of a Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints chapel in Michigan during a Sunday service attended by hundreds, opened fire and set the building ablaze. Police shot and killed the suspect, authorities said.
The attack occurred at about 10:25 a.m. The gunman got out of the four-door pickup with two American flags in the truck and started shooting, Police Chief William Renye told reporters. He apparently used gas to start the fire and also had explosive devices but it wasnât clear if he used them, said James Dier of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
Authorities identified the shooter as Thomas Jacob Sanford, 40, of the neighboring small town of Burton. The FBI is leading the investigation and considered it an âact of targeted violence,â said Ruben Coleman, a special agent in charge for the bureau.
Officers responding to a 911 call were at the church within 30 seconds and killed the shooter about eight minutes later, Renye said. After the suspect left the church, two officers pursued him and âengaged in gunfire,â the chief said.
Renye said people inside the church during the attack were âshielding childrenâ and âmoving them to safety.â
Flames and smoke could be seen pouring from the large church for hours before the blaze was put out. The bodies of two of the victims were found as authorities searched the debris, Renye said.
He said authorities had yet to make it though the entire church and that more victims could be found. One of the wounded people was in critical condition Sunday evening and the seven others were stable.
Renye said âsomeâ people were unaccounted for, but he didnât have an exact number.
Michigan State Police Lt. Kim Vetter said bomb threats were made at other churches in the area after officers shot and killed Sanford. No bombs were found and police were investigating the threats. The motive not yet clear
Investigators were searching Sanfordâs residence but authorities did not say what they found or provide any additional details about him, including whether he was a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, widely known as the Mormon church.
Sanford served in the Marines from June 2004 through June 2008, working as an automotive mechanic and vehicle recovery operator, according to military records obtained by The Detroit News. He was deployed to Iraq from August 2007 through March 2008 and had the rank of sergeant.
It was the latest of many shooting attacks on houses of worship in the US over the past 20 years, including one in August that killed two children during Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in Minneapolis.
It also was the second mass shooting in the US in less than 24 hours. On Saturday night, a man in a boat opened fire on a crowd in Southport, North Carolina, killing three and injuring five,
President Donald Trump said in a social media post that he was briefed on the Michigan shooting and applauded the FBI for its response. Local authorities said the FBI was sending 100 agents to Grand Blanc Township, a community of roughly 40,000 people outside Flint.
âPRAY for the victims, and their families. THIS EPIDEMIC OF VIOLENCE IN OUR COUNTRY MUST END, IMMEDIATELY!â Trump wrote.
The church building, circled by a parking lot and a large lawn, is near residential areas and a Jehovahâs Witness church.
Brad Schneemann, whose home is about 400 yards (365 meters) from the church, told The Associated Press that he and his daughter heard âtwo rounds of four to five shotsâ around 10:30 a.m. âThen, we really didnât hear anything for a whileâ before they left their home to see what was going on. Tight-knit church community
Timothy Jones, 48, said his family is part of another Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints congregation, or ward, about 15 minutes away, but that his children were at the Grand Blanc Township ward Saturday night for a youth fall festival. He and his family moved to Flint two years ago in large part because of how strong the faithâs community is in the area, he said.
As people in his congregation got word of the shooting from texts and phone calls during their Sunday service, his ward went into lockdown and police came as a precaution, he said. His children were âfrantically, just trying to get word that people were OK.â
Sundays are âsupposed to be a time of peace and a time of reflection and worship,â Jones said. Yet in the wake of violence at other houses of worship, a shooting âfeels inevitable, and all the more tragic because of that,â he added.
The shooting occurred the morning after Russell M. Nelson, the oldest-ever president of the Utah-based faith, died at 101. The next president is expected to be Dallin H. Oaks, per church protocol.
âThe church is in communication with local law enforcement as the investigation continues and as we receive updates on the condition of those affected,â spokesperson Doug Anderson said.
âPlaces of worship are meant to be sanctuaries of peacemaking, prayer and connection. We pray for peace and healing for all involved.â
People attend a prayer vigil held against violence, following a shooting that took place at the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, in Burton, Michigan, on Sept. 28, 2025. (REUTERS)
The impact of the shooting spread throughout the area
When striking nurses at nearby Henry Ford Genesys Hospital heard about the shooting, some left the picket line and ran the short distance to the church to help first responders, Teamsters Local 332 President Dan Glass said.
âHuman lives matter more than our labor dispute,â Glass said.
Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer said in a statement that her heart was breaking for the community. âViolence anywhere, especially in a place of worship, is unacceptable,â she said.
The impact spread quickly to neighboring communities, including the small city that shares a name with the township.
âAlthough we are two separate governmental units, we are a very cohesive community,â said city of Grand Blanc Mayor John Creasey. âThis sort of thing is painful for our entire community.â
About 100 people gathered for a prayer service Sunday evening at The River Church in Grand Blanc, a nondenominational Christian church about 5 miles (8 kilometers) from The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Many bowed their heads, some cried softly. A few spoke their prayers aloud, asking for healing for the victims, the victimsâ families and first responders.
âWe live in days that are difficult and troubled, days that are weary and tiring,â said Pastor Chuck Lindsey, leading the congregation in prayer. âWeâre exhausted by the evil, weâre exhausted by these things. But Lord, you are our refuge.â
Return of sanctions must not be end of diplomacy with Iran: EUâs top diplomat
Sustainable solution to nuclear issue can only be achieved through talks: Kallas
Updated 29 September 2025
AFP
BRUSSELS/TEHRAN: The return of widespread sanctions against Iranâs nuclear program âmust not be the end of diplomacyâ with the country, the EUâs top diplomat said on Sunday.
While the bloc will follow the UN in reimposing sanctions, âa sustainable solution to the Iranian nuclear issue can only be achieved through negotiations,â Kaja Kallas said.
The British, French and German foreign ministers said in a joint statement they would continue to seek âa new diplomatic solution to ensure Iran never gets a nuclear weapon.â
Iran condemned as âunjustifiableâ the reinstatement of sanctions.
âThe reactivation of annulled resolutions is legally baseless and unjustifiable ... all countries must refrain from recognizing this illegal situation,â the Iranian Foreign Ministry said.
Iran âwill firmly defend its national rights and interests, and any action aimed at undermining the rights and interests of its people will face a firm and appropriate response,â it added.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio urged Iran to âaccept direct talks, held in good faith.â
He also called on UN member states to âimmediatelyâ implement sanctions to âpressure Iranâs leaders to do what is right for their nation, and best for the safety of the world.â
Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian rejected any nuclear negotiations that would cause ânew problems.â
Frankly Speaking: Does anyone still trust âBrand UNâ?
Stephane Dujarric admits the Security Council has harmed the UNâs credibility, weakening global confidence and underscoring need for reform
Secretary-generalâs spokesperson stresses the UN is not a single centralized body, which is why Guterres cannot declare Gaza war a genocide
Updated 29 September 2025
Arab News
RIYADH: The UNâs credibility has been battered by paralysis at the Security Council, the war in Gaza, and accusations of inaction.
Stephane Dujarric, spokesperson for UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, admits the bodyâs failures have damaged âBrand UN.â While he insists reforms are on the agenda, he stresses that the world organization is not a single monolith.
Appearing on the Arab News current affairs program âFrankly Speaking,â during the UN General Assemblyâs High-level Week in New York City, Dujarric acknowledged the perception of dysfunction.
âThe credibility of the Security Council has taken a lot of hits recently,â he told âFrankly Speakingâ host Katie Jensen.
âWeâve seen a lack of unity on the part of the Security Council, not just on Gaza, but on Ukraine, on Syria when the Assad regime was in power, on Sudan. And that does hurt the UN brand in that sense, you are correct.â
Appearing on the Arab News current affairs program âFrankly Speaking,â during the UN General Assemblyâs High-level Week in New York City, Dujarric acknowledged the perception of dysfunction. (AN Photo)
Yet, he cautioned against treating the UN as a single actor. âIt is not an organization under a unified command,â he said. âIf the United Nations could speak with one voice, it would not be the United Nations we have today.â
The question of Gaza and whether Israelâs military campaign constitutes genocide has brought these contradictions into sharp relief. A UN Commission of Inquiry issued a landmark report on September 16 using the term, but Guterres has himself avoided using it.
Dujarric explained why. âThe secretary-general himself does not have the authority to declare something a genocide or not,â he said. âThat is, as far as we are concerned, and not just for Antonio Guterres, for every secretary-general, up to a judicial body.â
âWe should not be focused on semantics and on words. We are focused on the situation on the ground, regardless of whether or not you call it a genocide, what we do know is that civilians continue to be targeted and killed every day.
âPeople are under the state of famine in parts of Gaza and not enough aid is getting in. Thatâs the reality.â
Pressed on whether words matter, especially when Jewish scholars of the Holocaust are using the term, Dujarric rejected the idea that silence equates to complicity. âI mean, anyone who calls the secretary-general silent on Gaza, frankly, hasnât been listening,â he said.
He noted that Guterres has paid a price for his language already. âYouâre talking about a man who has been declared persona non grata in Israel because of the words heâs been using to describe the situation in Gaza,â he said.
âI think he has been a highly vocal advocate in terms of what is going on in Gaza. And he has been a very strong leader in ensuring that the men and women of the UN stay in Gaza to help the people.â
UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres waits for a press photo opportunity. (AFP via Getty)
Another flashpoint is the wave of states now announcing formal recognition of the State of Palestine, including the UK and France. Some critics, including US President Donald Trump, say doing so rewards Hamas for the Oct. 7, 2023, attack on Israel.
Dujarric dismissed the idea. âI donât really understand that argument, frankly, because Hamasâ goal is not a two-state solution. I donât see that in the Hamas Charter or in the rhetoric from Hamas,â he said.
âSo again, itâs not a gift to Hamas. On the contrary, it is recognizing the rights of the Palestinian people to have their state just as the Israelis have a right to have their state. And in fact, recognizing the two-state solution is a statement against extremists.â
Outrage over Israelâs conduct in Gaza has revived prospects for the two-state solution, with șÚÁÏÉçÇű and France arranging a UN summit pledging time-bound steps for an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel with no role for Hamas in its leadership.
While Israel and the US remain opposed, most world leaders now see two states as the only path to peace and regional stability after the Gaza war.
Dujarric was unequivocal that statehood is a Palestinian right. âLetâs put it frankly, itâs not a gift to the Palestinian people, but the right that they have to have a state, just like the Israelis have a right to have a state,â he said.
While diplomatic wrangling at the Security Council dominates, Dujarric said the daily humanitarian work that UN staff continue to undertake in Gaza and the West Bank remains critical.
âEven if thereâs a deadlock in the Security Council, it doesnât mean that our own people are not in Gaza trying to exploit the little humanitarian space theyâre being given to try to help the people of Gaza,â he said.
Dujarric said the UN Relief and Works Agency remains at the forefront of that response, despite attacks on its reputation and a squeeze on its funds after Israel accused members of its staff in Gaza of participating in the Oct. 7, 2023, attack.
âWe have UNRWA who is helping and supporting the Palestinian Authority. We will continue to do whatever we can,â he said.
However, he did stress that illegal Israeli settlement expansion, including the governmentâs approval for the new E1 settlement east of Jerusalem that will effectively bisect the West Bank, was creating new âfacts on the groundâ that would undermine hope of a Palestinian state.
The dysfunction of the Security Council, dominated by the veto power of its five permanent members, China, France, Russia, the UK, and the US, has prompted renewed calls for reform. Dujarric agreed that the system no longer reflects todayâs realities.
The dysfunction of the Security Council, dominated by the veto power of its five permanent members, China, France, Russia, the UK, and the US, has prompted renewed calls for reform. (Reuters/File Photo)
âWe need a reform of the Security Council because ⊠the Security Council is the beating heart of the UN in terms of peace and security,â he said. âIt remains a reflection of the world of 1945. The fact that it continues that way keeps hurting the UN brand globally.â
While he admitted reform remains distant, he said momentum is building. âThe membership is much more engaged in it now than it was from where I stood more than 10 years ago. So there is movement,â he said.
âThe secretary-general has been advocating very strongly for an African seat. The fact that Africa is the only continent that is not represented on the Security Council is abhorrent.â
âSome critics suggest that Guterres, frustrated by repeated US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolutions, should resign in protest. Dujarric dismissed this outright.
âI think resigning, for the secretary-general to resign, would be a gift for those people who find him a little too annoying. So he has absolutely no plans to resign. Heâs determined not to give up,â he said.
Instead, Guterres will continue to push on every possible diplomatic front, including quiet back-channel talks.
âHe has been very much in contact with the Qataris, the mediators. He stays in contact with the Egyptians. Weâve been using a lot of back channels and we will continue to push for a ceasefire to get humanitarian aid in, to see an end to the conflict and to see the hostages released,â he said.
Asked if the UN has become powerless, unable to fulfill its founding promise after the Second World War of ânever again,â Dujarric acknowledged failings, but defended Guterresâ resolve.
âI think the Security Council has not lived up to its promises in terms of being the focus of stopping wars and of peace and security,â he said.
âWe have to keep the promise of an end to conflict alive. The secretary-general will continue to advocate for it and not only advocate for it but to work for it through different means. And he will do so until the very last day of his mandate.â
For Dujarric, the UNâs future credibility depends not only on the secretary-generalâs persistence, but on whether member states are willing to modernize the system they created.
âMember states need to find a way to adapt their own organization, the UN, the one they created, to make it more effective, to make it more credible and to make it more representative of the world of 2025.â
Netanyahu to meet Trump as Israel faces isolation over Gaza war
Israelâs international isolation has deepened in recent days, with countries including the UK, France, Canada and Australia officially recognizing Palestinian statehood
Updated 28 September 2025
AFP
JERUSALEM: Facing increasing isolation abroad and mounting pressure at home, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will defend his intention to âfinish the jobâ in Gaza when he meets US President Donald Trump on Monday.
The meeting comes days after Trump unveiled a 21-point plan aimed at ending the war in the Palestinian territory during discussions with Arab and Muslim leaders on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly.
On Sunday, Trump hinted at âsomething specialâ to come in Middle East talks, adding in a post on his Truth Social platform: âWE WILL GET IT DONE!!!â
On Friday, Trump had told reporters in Washington âI think we have a dealâ on Gaza, even as Netanyahu, speaking at the UN, vowed to âfinish the jobâ in Israelâs war against Hamas.
But experts told AFP that Netanyahu appeared to be cornered, facing growing international and domestic calls to end the war.
âHe has no other choice but to acceptâ Trumpâs plan for a ceasefire, said Eytan Gilboa, an expert on US-Israel relations at Israelâs Bar-Ilan University.
âSimply because the United States and Trump have remained almost his only ally in the international community.â
âComprehensive agreementâ
In Israel, tens of thousands of protesters have pressured Netanyahu to agree to a ceasefire, and on Saturday they urged Trump to use his influence.
âThe only thing that can stop the slide into the abyss is a full, comprehensive agreement that ends the war and brings all the hostages and the soldiers home,â said Lishay Miran-Lavi, wife of Omri Miran, who remains captive in Gaza.
Directly addressing Trump, she urged: âUse your influence with Prime Minister Netanyahu.â
Israelâs international isolation has deepened in recent days, with countries including the UK, France, Canada and Australia officially recognizing Palestinian statehood, breaking with longstanding US-led diplomatic protocols.
Trumpâs 21-point plan, according to a diplomatic source, envisions a permanent ceasefire, the release of hostages, an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and a major influx of humanitarian aid.
Hamas political bureau member Hossam Badran said Sunday evening that the group âhad not received any official proposal from Qatari or Egyptian mediators.â
Arab and Muslim leaders have welcomed the proposal, but have also called for an immediate halt to Israelâs military operations and any occupation of Gaza.
Some elements of the plan will prove hard for Netanyahu to swallow, and could even lead to the collapse of his right-wing government coalition.
Among the most controversial is the involvement of the Ramallah-based Palestinian Authority (PA) in the future governance of Gaza.
The PA ruled the territory until Hamas seized control in 2007, and its potential restoration represents a red line for Netanyahuâs hard-line coalition partners.
While the US proposal conditions the PAâs return on implementing reform programs, these changes âcould take yearsâ to materialize, Gilboa warned.
âBroad consensusâ
Several far-right ministers in Netanyahuâs coalition have threatened to collapse the government if he agrees to the PAâs return, or if he ends the war without defeating Hamas.
However, opposition leader Yair Lapid has offered a parliamentary âsafety net,â promising his centrist Yesh Atid party would support a ceasefire and hostage-release deal â but it is not clear whether other opposition parties would follow suit.
âThis kind of broad plan would need a broad consensus,â said Ksenia Svetlova, a former Knesset member who now heads the regional cooperation NGO ROPES.
Svetlova predicted Netanyahu would only accept parts of the deal, while trying to negotiate or postpone decisions on other elements âseem difficult in this moment.â
Another contentious point in the US proposal is who would guarantee security in the Gaza Strip once the Israeli army pulls out and Hamas is disarmed.
The proposal envisions an international security force comprising Palestinian personnel alongside troops from Arab and Muslim nations.
However, critical details about command structure and operational control remain unclear.
âThis plan is internationalizing the Gaza conflict in an unprecedented way,â Svetlova said, âbut without a clear plan on who will be the guiding star, what the end goals are, who will see it through.â
âThe unpredictability factor runs wild here, really.â