Pakistani elephant Sonia dies less than two weeks after reunion with sister Madhubala

Pakistani elephant Sonia dies less than two weeks after reunion with sister Madhubala
Sister elephants Madhubala, Noor Jehan, Malika and Sonia are pictured at the Safari Park in Karachi, Pakistan, on November 27, 2024. (Four Paws)
Short Url
Updated 08 December 2024

Pakistani elephant Sonia dies less than two weeks after reunion with sister Madhubala

Pakistani elephant Sonia dies less than two weeks after reunion with sister Madhubala
  • Elephant’s post-mortem to be carried out on Monday, says international animal welfare organization
  • Sonia, sisters Madhubala, Malika and Noor Jehan, were brought from Tanzania to Pakistan in 2009

KARACHI: Pakistani elephant Sonia died at the Safari Park in Karachi on Sunday morning, an official said, less than two weeks after she was reunited with her sister Madhubala after a 15-year separation. 

Sisters Sonia, Malika, Noor Jehan and Madhubala were caught in the wild in Tanzania at a young age and brought to Pakistan together in 2009 but were soon separated, with Noor Jehan and Madhubala moved to the Karachi Zoo and Malika and Sonia to the city’s Safari Park. 

Noor Jehan died in April 2023 at age 17 after a prolonged illness caused by neglect, leaving Madhubala alone at the zoo. After a 15-year separation, Madhubala was shifted to the Safari Park on Nov. 26 where she was reunited with Malika and Sonia, who are estimated to be between 17 and 19 years old. 

“Sonia, one of the three elephants at Karachi’s Safari Park, passed away this morning,” Amjad Zaidi, director of the Safari Park, told Arab News.

“There were no health issues, and she appeared to be in perfect condition,” he said. 

Dr. Amir Khalil, director of the international animal welfare organization Four Paws, said a doctor from Lahore would conduct an autopsy examination on Sonia at Safari Park on Monday. 

“Based on this post-mortem report, it will be clear what factors led to the unexpected demise of Sonia,” Dr. Khalil told Arab News, highlighting that Sonia’s last medical report showed she was deficient in protein. 

Four Paws said last month that the three elephants’ health was being observed by head veterinarian Dr. Frank Goeritz from the Leibnitz Institute of Zoo and Wildlife Research, who has been involved in treating the elephants since 2021.

In November 2021, after the provincial Sindh High Court asked Four Paws to assess the Pakistani elephants’ well-being, all four were found to require better diet and medical treatment. 

Pakistan’s English-language daily Dawn reported in July that Sonia was found to have developed a swelling between her hind legs. Zaidi told Dawn that Sonia had developed the infection but was recovering. 

Animal rights activists have long campaigned against the plight of animals in Pakistan, especially elephants, and demanded that they be provided adequate medical care and nutrition. 


Lebanese woman fired from work after replying to post by Israeli military’s spokesman

Lebanese woman fired from work after replying to post by Israeli military’s spokesman
Updated 07 November 2025

Lebanese woman fired from work after replying to post by Israeli military’s spokesman

Lebanese woman fired from work after replying to post by Israeli military’s spokesman
  • Sarah Shayah replied to IDF’s spokesman Avichay Adraee, saying, ‘Baalbek when?’
  • Lawyer tells Arab News that interacting via social media with any Israeli is ‘against the Lebanese penal code’

BEIRUT: A Lebanese employee was fired from her job with immediate effect after her reply to a post by the Israeli military’s spokesman on X triggered a social media uproar.
Shortly after the Israel Defense Forces’ Arabic-language spokesman Avichay Adraee posted on X evacuation orders for residents of southern villages on Thursday, Lebanese citizen Sarah Shayah replied, saying: “Baalbek when?”
Without any clear indication as to what she meant by her reply, many social media users lashed out at Shayah, accusing her of communicating with Israelis and calling for her prosecution.
Others saw her reply as a joke or a simple error that should not have been taken so seriously.

Screenshot taken from social media shows Lebanese citizen Sarah Shayah’s reply to IDF’s Arabic-language spokesman Avichay Adraee’s post on X on Thursday. (Social Media)

According to Lebanese media, Shayah was an employee at the non-profit Lebanese Organization for Studies and Training.
LOST’s President Dr. Rami Al-Lakkis was quoted as telling Annahar newspaper that Shayah was immediately dismissed from her job. Citing a breach of the organization’s established procedures and regulations, Al-Lakkis emphasized that her actions constituted a violation of Lebanese laws, as they are considered communication with the enemy.
A lawyer specialized in criminal law told Arab News on Friday that interacting via social media with any Israeli is “against the Lebanese penal code.”
The lawyer, who requested anonymity, said: “A person who replies, retweets, or interacts with any social media account of any Israeli national is considered a form of communication with the enemy. If found guilty, a suspect could face no less than one year in jail.”
No confirmation could be obtained as to whether any legal action had been initiated against Shayah by the time this article was published.