The Australian Senate debates the world’s first social media ban for children under 16

The Australian Senate debates the world’s first social media ban for children under 16
Once the legislation becomes law, the platforms would have one year to work out how they could implement the ban before penalties are enforced. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 28 November 2024

The Australian Senate debates the world’s first social media ban for children under 16

The Australian Senate debates the world’s first social media ban for children under 16
  • The bill that would make social media platforms liable for fines of up to $33 million for systemic failures to prevent young children from holding accounts

MELBOURNE: The Australian Senate was debating a ban on children younger than 16 years old from social media Thursday after the House of Representatives overwhelmingly supported the age restriction.
The bill that would make platforms including TikTok, Facebook, Snapchat, Reddit, X and Instagram liable for fines of up to 50 million Australian dollars ($33 million) for systemic failures to prevent young children from holding accounts.
It is likely to be passed by the Senate on Thursday, the Parliament’s final session for the year and potentially the last before elections, which are due within months.
The major parties’ support for the ban all but guarantees the legislation will become law. But many child welfare and mental health advocates are concerned about unintended consequences.
Unaligned Sen. Jacqui Lambie complained about the limited amount of time the government gave the Senate to debate the age restriction, which she described as “undercooked.”
“I thought this was a good idea. A lot of people out there thought it was a good idea until we looked at the detail and, let’s be honest, there’s no detail,” Lambie told the Senate.
Opposition Sen. Maria Kovacic said the bill was not radical but necessary.
“The core focus of this legislation is simple: It demands that social media companies take reasonable steps to identify and remove underage users from their platforms,” Kovacic told the Senate.
“This is a responsibility these companies should have been fulfilling long ago, but for too long they have shirked these responsibilities in favor of profit,” she added.
Sen. David Shoebridge, from the minor Greens party, said mental health experts agreed that the ban could dangerously isolate many children who used social media to find support.
“This policy will hurt vulnerable young people the most, especially in regional communities and especially the LGBTQI community, by cutting them off,” Shoebridge told the Senate.
The House of Representatives on Wednesday overwhelmingly carried the bill 102 votes to 13.
Communications Minister Michelle Rowland urged senators to pass the bill which she said reflected the Australian community’s view.
“The ... government is on the side of supporting parents and protecting young people,” Rowland told the House.
Once the legislation becomes law, the platforms would have one year to work out how they could implement the ban before penalties are enforced.
The platforms complained that the law would be unworkable, and urged the Senate to delay the vote until at least June next year when a government-commissioned evaluation of age assurance technologies made its report on how young children could be excluded.
Critics argue the government is attempting to convince parents it is protecting their children ahead of general elections due by May. The government hopes that voters will reward it for responding to parents’ concerns about their children’s addiction to social media. Some argue the legislation could cause more harm than it prevents.
Criticisms include that the legislation was rushed through Parliament without adequate scrutiny, is ineffective, poses privacy risks for all users, and undermines parental authority to make decisions for their children.
Opponents of the bill also argue the ban would isolate children, deprive them of the positive aspects of social media, drive them to the dark web, discourage children too young for social media to report harm and reduce incentives for platforms to improve online safety.


UK mobile phones blare in national emergency test

UK mobile phones blare in national emergency test
Updated 07 September 2025

UK mobile phones blare in national emergency test

UK mobile phones blare in national emergency test
  • It was only the second test of the UK’s national emergency alert system following the first in 2023
  • In the past two years, the government has used the system five times to issue real warnings to local areas

LONDON: Millions of mobile phones across the UK blared a siren sound at the same time on Sunday as part of government efforts to better prepare for national emergencies.
The nationwide drill caused England’s third ODI cricket match against South Africa to be paused while kick-off for a rugby league match was pushed back to avoid disruption.
At 3:00 p.m. (1400 GMT), phones and tablets emitted the noise and vibrated for about 10 seconds, while users also received a message saying it was just a test.
It was only the second test of the country’s national emergency alert system following the first in 2023.
The government had in recent weeks embarked on a publicity drive to minimize any shock caused, including through announcements at rail stations and signs on motorways.
It has used the system to issue real warnings to local areas five times in the past two years.
In January, some 4.5 million people in Scotland and Northern Ireland received an alert during Storm Eowyn after a red weather warning was issued, meaning there was a risk to life.
A 500-kilogramme (1,100-pound) unexploded Second World War bomb found in a back garden in southwest England triggered a warning to some 50,000 phones in February last year.
The system is designed for use during the most likely emergencies to affect Britain where there is the possibility of a loss of life.
Warnings would also be transmitted on television, radio and where appropriate by knocking on doors.
Similar alerts are issued in the United States and Japan.
Only devices connected to 4G or 5G networks received Sunday’s alert.
It came as officials seek to strengthen the country’s resilience amid more frequent extreme weather events and concerns around Russia’s war in Ukraine.
The government published a “Resilience Action Plan” in July which also cited the upheaval of the coronavirus pandemic, US President Donald Trump’s tariffs and cyberattacks.


‘Five Eyes’ ministers meet to discuss smashing people smuggling gangs, UK says

MP Shabana Mahmood, who has been appointed to the role of Home Secretary, walks towards 10 Downing Street.
MP Shabana Mahmood, who has been appointed to the role of Home Secretary, walks towards 10 Downing Street.
Updated 07 September 2025

‘Five Eyes’ ministers meet to discuss smashing people smuggling gangs, UK says

MP Shabana Mahmood, who has been appointed to the role of Home Secretary, walks towards 10 Downing Street.
  • As well as people smuggling, the group will discuss new measures to tackle those behind child sexual abuse online and how to stop the spread of deadly synthetic opioids

LONDON: Homeland ministers from Britain, the United States and the other “Five Eyes” alliance will announce new measures this week to increase border security and target people smugglers, British interior minister Shabana Mahmood said on Sunday.
The ministers from the Five Eyes intelligence sharing network — the US, Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand — will meet in London on Monday and Tuesday, Britain’s Home Office said, with measures to “smash criminal smuggling gangs” the focus of the talks.
“We will agree new measures to protect our borders with our Five Eyes partners, hitting people smugglers hard,” Mahmood, who was only appointed to her job on Friday after Prime Minister Keir Starmer reshuffled his ministers.
Countries across the world are wrestling with how to deal with the issue of migration, with the US President Donald Trump making a crackdown on legal and illegal immigration a central plank of his second White House term.
In Britain, it has become the dominant political topic, with the government under great pressure from rivals over how to deal with a record number of asylum claims and arrivals by migrants in small boats across the Channel.
Joining Mahmood for the talks will be US Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, Canada’s Gary Anandasangaree, Tony Burke, Australia’s Home Affairs Minister, and Judith Collins from New Zealand.
As well as people smuggling, the group will discuss new measures to tackle those behind child sexual abuse online and how to stop the spread of deadly synthetic opioids, the Home Office said.


Palestinian PM and UK foreign secretary discuss post-war Gaza, UN General Assembly

Palestinian PM and UK foreign secretary discuss post-war Gaza, UN General Assembly
Updated 07 September 2025

Palestinian PM and UK foreign secretary discuss post-war Gaza, UN General Assembly

Palestinian PM and UK foreign secretary discuss post-war Gaza, UN General Assembly
  • Mohammad Mustafa and Yvette Cooper discussed preparations for the upcoming UN General Assembly, where several countries have pledged to recognize the State of Palestine
  • Both sides discussed post-war governance of Gaza affairs, as well as recent Israeli attacks in West Bank

LONDON: Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa spoke on Sunday with the newly appointed UK Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper about efforts to achieve a ceasefire in the Gaza Strip and a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Mustafa and Cooper discussed preparations for the upcoming UN General Assembly, where several countries have pledged to recognize the State of Palestine.

They also discussed collaborating on the outcomes of the Saudi-French co-chaired conference held last July, which aimed to revive the peace process in the region.

The UK plans to recognize Palestine at the UN this month unless Israel agrees to a ceasefire in Gaza and to engage in the two-state solution.

Both sides discussed post-war governance of Gaza affairs, as well as recent attacks by Israeli forces and settlers in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem, the Wafa news agency reported.

They highlighted the need for ongoing cooperation to stop Israeli aggressions, including settlement expansion and annexation, in the West Bank.

Cooper reaffirmed the UK’s strategic partnership with Palestine and support for its statehood, emphasizing the commitment to ending the Gaza war and facilitating humanitarian aid, according to Wafa.


Foreign aid cuts, isolation weaken Afghanistan’s earthquake response

An Afghan man receives treatment in a corn field, after earthquakes in Mazar Dara village in Noorgal district, Kunar province.
An Afghan man receives treatment in a corn field, after earthquakes in Mazar Dara village in Noorgal district, Kunar province.
Updated 07 September 2025

Foreign aid cuts, isolation weaken Afghanistan’s earthquake response

An Afghan man receives treatment in a corn field, after earthquakes in Mazar Dara village in Noorgal district, Kunar province.
  • 80 clinics in affected regions closed this year after US aid cuts, leaving 15% of population without healthcare
  • First responders reported how rescuers walked for hours, used bare hands to pull survivors from the rubble

KABUL: As rescue operations continued in eastern Afghanistan on Sunday, a week after a deadly earthquake devastated the region, World Health Organization and doctor accounts show how the withdrawal of foreign aid has undermined the country’s ability to respond to disasters.

At least 2,205 people have been killed and another 3,640 injured by the quake that hit the densely populated rural areas of Kunar and Nangarhar provinces on Aug. 31.

While the Afghan government quickly flew dozens of doctors to support overwhelmed hospitals and sent helicopters to reach the wounded, many mountain villages were cut off by landslides. First responders reported how poorly equipped rescuers had to walk for hours to reach the affected areas and often used basic tools and even their bare hands to pull survivors from the rubble.

The WHO, whose teams are also on the ground, said in its situation report on Saturday evening that timely emergency response and access to higher-level care for critical cases was limited by “severe shortages” of functioning vehicles, fuel and sustained health services.

“Afghanistan’s fragile health system — already strained by prolonged humanitarian crises and widespread poverty — faces chronic shortages of medicines and staff,” the WHO said, citing a gap of $4 million only for its own life-saving interventions, amid a widespread shortage of funding among all UN agencies and other aid groups operating in the country.

Cuts in international aid for Afghanistan followed the collapse of its Western-backed regime to the Taliban in 2021. When US-led troops subsequently withdrew from the country, international donors also froze all projects overnight, after spending billions on two decades of military and development operations.

This also disrupted the state health program, which previously funded about 75 percent of Afghan health services, leading to facility closures and staffing disruptions.

After a brief infusion of humanitarian support, funding cuts resumed by late 2022 and into 2023 — resulting in more closure of health facilities, particularly those run by nongovernmental organizations.

The US government’s decision in February to further cut funding to Afghanistan has since led to the closure of 422 health facilities across the country.

At least 80 clinics were suspended or closed in four provinces of the eastern region — Nangarhar, Kunar, Laghman and Nuristan — that were hit by the earthquake last week, leaving 15 percent of their 4 million population without critical care.

“Several villages still have no access to medical teams,” a doctor assisting the injured in Kunar province told Arab News on Sunday, as rescuers were still looking for survivors.

“In some remote villages, people remain trapped under the rubble, and the number of casualties continues to rise daily … There is an urgent need for mobile health teams equipped with essential medicines and trained medical personnel.”

Afghan doctors have been warning for months that foreign funding cuts were depriving the country’s most vulnerable of healthcare, especially in rural areas, where aid-dependent NGOs are the sole providers.

“Afghanistan’s public health system has long relied on international funding … Although the current administration has made efforts to keep the system afloat, these measures have fallen short,” said Dr. Ahmad Obaid Mujadidi, clinical consultant and CEO of Rifah Hospital in Kabul.

Less than 3 percent of Afghanistan’s annual health spending comes from the national budget, while nearly 78 percent is paid out of pocket by citizens.

Due to the lack of medical facilities in the quake-affected areas, many of the wounded were taken to the nearest hospital in Jalalabad, some 120 km from the worst-hit Noorgal district in Kunar.

“The recent earthquake has placed enormous strain on an already fragile and underfunded health system. Critical health infrastructure in the affected areas sustained damage, while major hospitals such as Nangarhar Regional Hospital — receiving a high influx of injured patients — have seen their routine services severely disrupted,” Mujadidi said.

“Without coordinated international support, post-disaster recovery will remain out of reach … Short-term health interventions spanning six to 12 months are urgently needed, particularly those targeting maternal and child healthcare, as well as the prevention of communicable diseases. However, the crisis extends beyond immediate relief. Long-term, sustainable investment is essential.”


Police arrest almost 900 at London protest supporting banned group Palestine Action

Man reacts as police officers operate during a rally challenging the British government’s proscription of “Palestine Action.”
Man reacts as police officers operate during a rally challenging the British government’s proscription of “Palestine Action.”
Updated 07 September 2025

Police arrest almost 900 at London protest supporting banned group Palestine Action

Man reacts as police officers operate during a rally challenging the British government’s proscription of “Palestine Action.”
  • Almost 1,600 people have now been detained, many for silently holding signs supporting the group, since it was outlawed two months ago

LONDON: British police said Sunday that they arrested almost 900 people demonstrating in London against a ban on the group Palestine Action, which has been deemed a terrorist organization by the government.
Almost 1,600 people have now been detained, many for silently holding signs supporting the group, since it was outlawed two months ago. Protesters say the ban on Palestine Action is an unwarranted curb on free speech and the right to protest.
The Metropolitan Police force said 890 people were arrested at Saturday’s demonstration, the vast majority, 857, under the Terrorism Act for supporting a proscribed organization. Some 33 were detained for other offenses, including 17 for assaulting police officers.
Defend Our Juries, the campaign group organizing the protest, said 1,500 people took part in the demonstration outside Parliament, sitting down and holding signs reading “I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.”
Within minutes, police began arresting the demonstrators, as bystanders chanted “Shame on you,” and “Met Police, pick a side, justice or genocide.” There were some scuffles and angry exchanges as officers dragged away demonstrators who went limp as they were removed from the crowd.
“In carrying out their duties today, our officers have been punched, kicked, spat on and had objects thrown at them by protesters,” said Deputy Assistant Commissioner Claire Smart, who called the abuse directed at police “intolerable.”
Defend Our Juries said aggression had come from police officers and dismissed claims that protesters had been violent as “frankly laughable.”
More than 700 people were arrested at earlier protests, and 138 have been charged under the Terrorism Act.
Mike Higgins, 62, who is blind and uses a wheelchair, was arrested last month but returned to demonstrate on Saturday.
“And I’m a terrorist? That’s the joke of it,” he said. “I’ve already been arrested under the Terrorism Act and I suspect I will be today.
“Of course I’ll keep coming back. What choice do I have?”
Direct action protests
The government proscribed Palestine Action in July, after activists broke into a Royal Air Force base and vandalized planes to protest against what they called Britain’s support for Israel’s offensive against Hamas in Gaza. The activists sprayed red paint into the engines of two tanker planes and caused further damage with crowbars.
Proscription made it a crime to publicly support the organization. Membership of, or support for, the group is punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
Palestine Action has carried out direct action protests in the UK since it formed in 2020, including breaking into facilities owned by Israeli weapons manufacturer Elbit Systems UK, and has targeted other sites in Britain that participants believe have links with the Israeli military.
The group has targeted defense companies and national infrastructure, and officials say their actions have caused millions of pounds in damage that affect national security.
Banning the group, then-Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said, “The assessments are very clear, this is not a nonviolent organization.”
Palestine Action has won approval from the High Court to challenge the ban, a ruling the government is seeking to overturn. The case is ongoing, with a hearing scheduled for Sept. 25.
Supporters say the ban stifles free speech
The UN human rights chief has criticized the British government’s stance, saying the new law “misuses the gravity and impact of terrorism.”
The decision to designate Palestine Action as a terrorist group “raises serious concerns that counterterrorism laws are being applied to conduct that is not terrorist in nature, and risks hindering the legitimate exercise of fundamental freedoms across the UK,” Volker Türk warned.
He added that according to international standards, terrorist acts should be confined to crimes such as those intended to cause death or serious injury or the taking of hostages.
Huda Ammori, Palestine Action’s co-founder, has condemned the government’s decision to ban it as “catastrophic” for civil liberties, leading to a “much wider chilling effect on freedom of speech.”
The group has been supported by prominent cultural figures including bestselling Irish author Sally Rooney, who said she planned to use the proceeds of her work “to keep backing Palestine Action and direct action against genocide.”
Israel — founded in part as a refuge in the wake of the Holocaust, when some 6 million European Jews were murdered — vehemently denies it is committing genocide.
Britain’s government stressed that proscribing Palestine Action as a terrorist group does not affect other lawful groups — including pro-Palestinian or pro-Israel voices — campaigning or peacefully protesting.
About 20,000 people, by a police estimate, attended a separate pro-Palestinian march in London on Saturday.